There’s some really delightful news spreading far and wide this summer: Costco’s best-selling ice cream is making a comeback, and they’ve introduced some fantastic new flavors that everyone is talking about! People all over are buzzing with excitement.
Costco has brought back the much-loved Nightingale Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Sandwiches, which so many people remember and enjoy. They’ve also introduced the brand new Dubai Chocolate Pistachio Ice Cream Bars, which are quickly becoming a viral sensation. These creamy and delicious treats are proving to be incredibly popular, and they’re actually selling out very quickly in stores! It’s a wonderful sign that people are finding joy and a little bit of summer happiness in these delicious ice cream creations.
From a 10-year-old’s delight to food-industry pros tracking cold-chain trends, this article digs into the flavors, the frenzy, and why these treats are more than just frozen dessert—they’re community culture on ice.
Costco’s Best-Selling Ice Cream Comeback
| Treat | Flavor & Format | Price & Size | Availability & Insights |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches | Strawberry Shortcake: 14% butterfat strawberry ice cream between brown-sugar cookies (18 “chomp-size”) | Exclusive to 132+ East Coast Costcos; sells out in days due to high demand (foodandwine.com). Fans urging national rollout. | | |
| Dubai Chocolate Pistachio Bars | Pistachio ice cream with kataifi-coated chocolate, by Afters Ice Cream, in boxes of 10 | $17.99 per box (~$1.80 each) | Debuted at Coachella, now flying off Costco freezers nationwide . Causing minor pistachio price hike (foxnews.com). |
| Ricco Sea Salt Caramel Sandwiches | Caramel gelato between snickerdoodle-style cookies (Texas region) | $15.99 for 8-pack | Available in select Texas stores; fans are stockpiling upon launch . |
Costco is doing more than just selling delicious frozen treats; they’re actually helping to create wonderful moments for families and friends across the country! Imagine sharing a delightful, bite-sized strawberry treat with your loved ones, or perhaps trying one of those viral Dubai-inspired ice cream bars that everyone is talking about. These aren’t just flavors; they are sparking connection, enjoyment, and a sense of shared happiness among people.
These ice creams are truly perfect for sharing in bulk, bringing smiles to gatherings big and small. They come dipped in a bit of nostalgia for many, reminding us of simpler, joyful times, and are sprinkled with social love as people excitedly share their favorite finds online. So, these aren’t just any ordinary ice creams you grab from the freezer. They’re actually becoming memorable summer stories, ready to be enjoyed and shared by communities nationwide.
Nightingale’s Strawberry Shortcake Sandwiches
Last year’s Cookie Monster burst onto the scene and practically vanished from shelves in under a week. Now, Strawberry Shortcake is back—with handmade freshness in every bite: real fruit puree, 14% butterfat, and brown sugar cookies (foodandwine.com).
Food & Wine praises this flavor for its “depth of flavor and chewy cookie texture.” At only $1.11 each, the 18-packed treats are chomp-size joy—especially for families.
Pro Tip: Follow Instagram pages like @nightingaleicecream and @CostcoFoodReviews. Tag your local Costco to help push for expanded availability.
Dubai Chocolate Pistachio Ice Cream Bars
Great news for those with a sweet tooth! Costco has now officially joined the popular Dubai Chocolate trend. The viral dessert sensation from Afters Ice Cream, which was a huge hit at Coachella, has now arrived in Costco freezers. Imagine delicious pistachio ice cream completely covered in rich chocolate and a delightful kataifi crunch!
Getting ten of these amazing bars for just $17.99 (that’s only about $1.80 each!) makes it a truly affordable treat. Even the Food Network has raved about them, calling them “fire”! People on Reddit are also excited, pointing out that these same bars cost around $13 each at festivals, and now you can enjoy them in the comfort of your own home. One interesting side effect of this popularity is that the price of pistachios has seen a slight increase because there’s so much demand for this delicious flavor. It’s wonderful to see such a tasty treat becoming more accessible for everyone to enjoy!
Ricco Gelato Sea Salt Caramel Sandwiches
For our Texas neighbors, there’s a delicious treat you won’t want to miss! Ricco Gelato Sea Salt Caramel ice cream sandwiches feature a heavenly combination: salted caramel gelato nestled between chewy, snickerdoodle-style cookies.
These aren’t just any ice cream sandwiches; they’re a special experience, and at 8 sandwiches for just $15.99, they’re a great way to share a moment of joy with family and friends. It’s wonderful to see how something as simple as a sweet treat can bring people together and create a little bit of happiness in our day.
Related Links
Turn Leftover Veggies into a Tasty Protein Meal – Try This Simple Oven or Air Fryer Recipe
It’s Back! McDonald’s Confirms the Return of a Fan-Favorite Menu Millions Begged For
Costco and Target Are Opening New Stores in Texas — Here’s Where and What to Expect
Summer Scoop Tips
- Split the box – Freeze extras to stretch the fun.
- Let them thaw – Sit 1–2 minutes before unboxing for optimal texture.
- Use the Costco app – Check inventory and scan freezers ahead of trips.
- Make it a float – Costco’s $1.99 ice cream + $0.75 soda = epic float hack.
- Share the love – Food content creators tagging brands help signal demand.
Tradition Meets Trend
In many Native American traditions, food is shared, honored, and celebrated as part of community and season. Costco’s ice cream trends bring people together—for backyard laughter, family rituals, and scoop-sharing stories. That’s more than nostalgia—it’s honoring the moment, one chill bite at a time.
FAQs
Q: Where can I buy the Strawberry Shortcake sandwiches?
A: Exclusively in Costco stores from Virginia to Maine. Over 132 East Coast locations. Check local stock.
Q: Are Dubai Chocolate Bars limited supply?
A: Yes, they drop sometimes unexpectedly. Try weekends after restocks. They go fast.
Q: Allergens included?
A: Contains dairy, wheat, nuts (pistachio). Read labels carefully—important for dietary needs.
Q: Will these flavors expand nationally?
A: It’s possible. Social media buzz often drives wider rollout. Keep tagging and posting!
Q: How long will they stay?
A: Seasonal hits often return next summer. Refrigerated love has to wait, but we hope to see them again!
